Welcome to Secret Guitars - A Vintage Music Shop in Toms River, NJ

Musician owned and staffed since 2015

A row of marshall electric guitars hanging from the ceiling

Your one-stop shop for high end musical gear, professional studio recordings, and instrument repairs in Toms River, NJ

Searching for a classic vintage guitar? Need a guitar repaired before the next big gig? Come to Secret Guitars in Toms River, NJ. People come to our shop from all around the Tri-State area knowing they will receive great expertise about our ever-changing gear and merchandise as well as attentive care and precision on any type of instrument repair. Check out our online shop, we also ship anywhere within the U.S and internationally if we have the guitar you need!



Also looking to sell or trade gear? We buy guitars, basses, drums, keyboards, microphones, and all other musical equipment for great prices. Come on down and see the shop!

About Us

Practice Space

Lessons

Instrument Repairs

They don’t make guitars like they used to
Check out our vintage instruments for sale

We’re the best-kept secret in Ocean County

Whether you're in a band or you’ve never touched a guitar before, the team at Secret Guitars can help you out. We offer:

Used amps, banjos, mandolins, accordions and guitars

Professional amp and instrument repair services

One-on-one bass, drum and guitar lessons

Hourly sessions in our practice space

Recording sessions at our studio

Reach out today to learn more about what we offer.

Serving our community since 2015

At Secret Guitars, we proudly share our passion and knowledge with the musical community of New Jersey and the surrounding states, and even countries! We offer lessons, repairs, awesome new and used gear, professional recordings, and more for some of the best deals in the industry right now. We also buy all types of gear for cash. Whether you want to sell a guitar you haven't played in years, or you are looking for a vintage instrument for sell, you will be glad you walked into Secret Guitars.


Come check out our new and used instrument selection!

A room filled with lots of guitars hanging on a wall

What My Clients Say

Sam Bianchi

Great selection, and Mike is an awesome dude! Knows his stuff, very friendly, and great service! Will be dropping by every now and then for sure!

Joseph Keating

I love the owner Magic Mike. He is the coolest dude on the planet. It is an honor to know and do business with him he is fair and honest. I recommend Secret guitars for beginners and pros alike. The selection of guitars and amps is crazy. Worth a visit! I only buy and sell to Mike. The staff are also great but I'm spoiled.

David Gallo

I'm a new guitar trainee. Everyone here is helpful and patient. Especially Phil for lessons. Great place.

David K

Knowledgeable friendly musicians with great gear. Stepping in feels like a Time Machine.

Jose F

The guys helped my son and me choose his first guitar. They were very helpful and kind.

Laura Costello

Make sure you go to this store first. You won't be disappointed. Best knowledgeable staff.

Great experience 😁 …

Michael Erikson

aul is a legend. He is an amazing luthier. He can fix and create anything with strings. I truly would not go anywhere else. High quality repairs and custom work.

Days 4Days

Jon was great! Very personable while helping my son find a guitar, never pressured for the sale, showed real concern for helping him find the right guitar even though we didn’t find it there…would definitely recommend to others

Scott Cleveland

Great, hidden gem of a store with a lot of merch and other cool artifacts.

justin kowalsky

I think this is the same place great shop really cool guy knowledgeable

Sam Bianchi

Great selection, and Mike is an awesome dude! Knows his stuff, very friendly, and great service! Will be dropping by every now and then for sure!

Joseph Keating

I love the owner Magic Mike. He is the coolest dude on the planet. It is an honor to know and do business with him he is fair and honest. I recommend Secret guitars for beginners and pros alike. The selection of guitars and amps is crazy. Worth a visit! I only buy and sell to Mike. The staff are also great but I'm spoiled.

Google My Business Badge. Click to review

Come check out our new and used instruments selection!

Contact Us

All fields marked with an asterisk * are required